: Reviewers from The Wall Street Journal noted a "glaring lapse" where Brown describes Gibson's gender nonconformity as "expansively queer" despite admitting a lack of evidence regarding intimate female partners. Children's Books

: Some readers on The StoryGraph found the 18-hour audiobook version a "slog," noting it is very detailed and sometimes repetitive regarding match play.

:

: Critics appreciate that Jacobs doesn't "soften" Gibson’s early life, providing a realistic portrait of her "steeliness" and complex, often "aggressive" personality.

: Highly praised as a "grand slam" by The Washington Informer and The Philadelphia Tribune .

: