Reviews for the track have been polarized, reflecting the tension between Madonna's legacy and her pursuit of modern relevance:

: Producer Sickick strips the original’s orchestral drama for a "trippy," bass-heavy trap beat characterized by deep rumbles and "icy," alien soundscapes.

: Unlike previous remixes featuring guest artists like 070 Shake or Fireboy DML, "Frozen On Fire" features fresh vocals from both Madonna and Sickick himself.